Hey everyone. Im looking to pick up a shiner swimbait and i would love any and all feedback/opinions on which way to go. I have basically narrowed it down to the RealPrey 7" Golden Shiner (or the jumbo 8.5") or the Savage Gear 10" Roach in Golden Shiner. I know a lot of people always side with the custom baits, but looking for unbiased opinions on the baits themselves for my situation/location.
Little background. I'm from Maine and i fish a lot of smaller (under 200 acre) ponds in a kayak. Most ponds around here have a good amount of vegetation. And i do enjoy fishing in and around it. So this is going to be my first season dedicating to bigger swimbaits. In the past i have fished swimbaits a lot (4.5" to the 5.8 Keitechs) on cheaper MH combos. This winter i have purchased an Okuma Guide Select XXH rod (rated 2-10 oz) with a Daiwa Tatula 200HD. Im wanting to focus on lures in the 8 to 10" range. So far i have purchased a BBZ-1 8" slow sink trout and will be buying a 9" MS Slammer soon.
In my reasearch, no doubt the realprey is a nice bait. At $24 the 7" is a good price (so is the 8.5 as well) and i can get the SG 10" for the same price. I like the action i see online with the SG, as it looks like it can be fished like a glide along with the usual "S" swim of a swimbait. I would also think the SG is very durable, as they design their baits to the pike crowd. My biggest concern with the two is the durability from fishing in waters with a lot of pickerel. I have had the 5.8 keitechs tails bit off on one cast. dont want to happen with a $24 bait (so maybe the Gantarel is the better choice??). I also plan to pick up a glide bait as well, so i dont "need" the glide action from the shiner. Just seems like a bonus.
Curious to hear opinions. Thanks in advance.