Keep the top hook, if you ask me. If a fish wants it enough it will take the bait. Some people bend it slightly outward to increase hookup ratio, but when I start getting tail bites like that I either adjust the presentation or change up completely. Don't know if it's true or not but it's been said adding a stinger on the bottom of the bait can increase the chance of hooking the big fish that actually does inhale it in it's gills, resulting in the death of that fish. Anyways good luck and keep chucking it, you'll get one to commit!