Pretty much my favorite way to fish - if you've ever night fished with a Jitterbug, night Slammer fishing isn't much different, just up-sized. I've caught fish on both the 1x and 2x, but like the 1x better because it fouls less. Don't be afraid to throw the larger sizes, I've caught 1 and 2 pound fish on the 12" Don't worry too much about color; I've caught fish on shad, frog, perch, and white baits both day and night, just buy what you think looks cool and you have confidence in.