I personally like beat up baits better, ones I have caught fish with or not I have more confidence in them for whatever reason haha so therefore they work better cause I throw them more. On that note, pretty sure the fish don't care/know the difference.
As @KeepinItReelFishing mentioned, I second the 2 Faced waking gill. Killer action, full/big profile, very solid made bait and Steven is a super cool guy.